SIDE BY SIDE

Mageia vs PCLinuxOS

Mageia: A community fork of Mandriva with its own control center. PCLinuxOS: A long-running independent rolling desktop. Here is how they differ, and which one suits you.

Mageia or PCLinuxOS: the short answer

Mageia and PCLinuxOS take different approaches to almost everything that matters day to day. Pick Mageia if you care most about long-term stability. Pick PCLinuxOS if you care most about gaming and latest software.

Quick verdict

  • GamingPCLinuxOSPCLinuxOS gets newer drivers and kernels faster.
  • Latest softwarePCLinuxOSPCLinuxOS uses a rolling model; Mageia is stable.
  • Long-term stabilityMageiaMageia changes less between upgrades.

Scored from our catalog data (experience level, release model, suggested RAM, intended uses), not from benchmarks. How we build the catalog

Specs compared

Memory figures are editorial planning suggestions, not measured consumption or official minimums. Popularity measures attention, not quality.

FeatureMageiaPCLinuxOS
Popularity rank (30d)#46#43
Popularity trend (30d)Down 6%Up 1%
Based onIndependent (Mandriva fork)Independent (Mandriva heritage)
Release modelStableRolling
DesktopKDE Plasma, GNOME, XfceKDE Plasma, MATE, Xfce
Package managementurpmi · DNFAPT-RPM · Synaptic
Init systemsystemdsysVinit
Experience levelBeginnerBeginner
Suggested RAM4 GB+4 GB+
Architecturesx86_64x86_64
First released20112003
PriceFreeFree
Good forEveryday useEveryday use

Key differences

  • Mageia is an independent distribution; PCLinuxOS is an independent distribution.
  • Mageia follows a stable release model; PCLinuxOS is rolling.
  • Mageia ships KDE Plasma, GNOME, Xfce; PCLinuxOS ships KDE Plasma, MATE, Xfce.
  • Software comes from urpmi · DNF on Mageia and APT-RPM · Synaptic on PCLinuxOS.
  • Mageia uses systemd as its init system; PCLinuxOS uses sysVinit.

Mageia: strengths and tradeoffs

  • central graphical control center
  • community governance
  • fixed, predictable releases

Release gaps can be long

Full Mageia profile

PCLinuxOS: strengths and tradeoffs

  • rolling without reinstalling
  • graphical package management
  • systemd-free

64-bit only; small package team

Full PCLinuxOS profile

Switching between Mageia and PCLinuxOS

From Mageia to PCLinuxOS

  • You will swap urpmi for APT-RPM; package names and install commands differ, so check your must-have apps on PCLinuxOS first.
  • You can keep KDE Plasma, which both offer, so your layout and shortcuts mostly carry over.
  • PCLinuxOS is rolling: updates arrive continuously, so update often and keep backups.

From PCLinuxOS to Mageia

  • You will swap APT-RPM for urpmi; package names and install commands differ, so check your must-have apps on Mageia first.
  • You can keep KDE Plasma, which both offer, so your layout and shortcuts mostly carry over.
  • Mageia is a fixed release: fewer surprise changes, but you upgrade to a new version every so often.

Either way, back up your home folder, then do a clean install; reusing a separate /home partition works but can bring old settings that clash.

Mageia vs PCLinuxOS: FAQ

Is Mageia better than PCLinuxOS?

Neither is better for everyone. Mageia is the stronger pick for long-term stability; PCLinuxOS for gaming, latest software.

Which is more popular, Mageia or PCLinuxOS?

On our 30-day popularity ranking PCLinuxOS is #43 and Mageia is #46. Popularity measures attention, not quality. Over the same period interest in PCLinuxOS is up 1% and Mageia is down 6%.

Which uses less RAM, Mageia or PCLinuxOS?

Both need about 4 GB of RAM for a comfortable desktop. The desktop environment affects memory use more than the distribution.

Is Mageia based on PCLinuxOS?

No. Mageia is based on Independent (Mandriva fork); PCLinuxOS is based on Independent (Mandriva heritage).

Related comparisons

Add a third distro to this comparison