SIDE BY SIDE

Devuan vs Vanilla OS

Devuan: Debian without systemd, with a choice of init. Vanilla OS: An immutable GNOME desktop with containers for any package. Here is how they differ, and which one suits you.

Devuan or Vanilla OS: the short answer

Devuan and Vanilla OS take different approaches to almost everything that matters day to day. Pick Devuan if you care most about older hardware and long-term stability. Pick Vanilla OS if you care most about gaming and latest software.

Quick verdict

  • GamingVanilla OSVanilla OS gets newer drivers and kernels faster.
  • Older hardwareDevuanDevuan needs about 2 GB of RAM versus 4 GB.
  • Latest softwareVanilla OSVanilla OS uses a atomic model; Devuan is stable.
  • Long-term stabilityDevuanDevuan changes less between upgrades.

Scored from our catalog data (experience level, release model, suggested RAM, intended uses), not from benchmarks. How we build the catalog

Specs compared

Memory figures are editorial planning suggestions, not measured consumption or official minimums. Popularity measures attention, not quality. Missing data is shown as a dash.

FeatureDevuanVanilla OS
Popularity rank (30d)#37Not ranked
Popularity trend (30d)Down 4%—
Based onDebianDebian Sid
Release modelStableAtomic
DesktopXfce, KDE Plasma, moreGNOME
Package managementAPTApx · Flatpak
Init systemsysVinit, OpenRC or runitsystemd
Experience levelIntermediateIntermediate
Suggested RAM2 GB+4 GB+
Architecturesx86_64x86_64
First released20142022
PriceFreeFree
Good forServers, Everyday use, Older hardwareImmutable systems, Development, Everyday use

Key differences

  • Devuan is based on Debian; Vanilla OS is based on Debian Sid.
  • Devuan follows a stable release model; Vanilla OS is atomic.
  • Devuan ships Xfce, KDE Plasma, more; Vanilla OS ships GNOME.
  • Software comes from APT on Devuan and Apx · Flatpak on Vanilla OS.
  • Devuan uses sysVinit, OpenRC or runit as its init system; Vanilla OS uses systemd.
  • We suggest about 2 GB of RAM for Devuan and 4 GB for Vanilla OS.

Devuan: strengths and tradeoffs

  • choice of init system
  • debian-compatible packages
  • suitable for servers and desktops

Some software expects systemd

Full Devuan profile

Vanilla OS: strengths and tradeoffs

  • atomic A/B updates
  • apx for packages from other distributions
  • vanilla GNOME experience

Young project with changing tooling

Full Vanilla OS profile

Switching between Devuan and Vanilla OS

From Devuan to Vanilla OS

  • You will swap APT for Apx; package names and install commands differ, so check your must-have apps on Vanilla OS first.
  • The desktop changes from Xfce, KDE Plasma, more to GNOME; expect a different layout, settings app and shortcuts.
  • Vanilla OS is atomic: the base system is read-only and updates apply as a whole image you can roll back; most apps come from Flatpak or containers.
  • Plan for a bit more memory: we suggest about 4 GB for Vanilla OS versus 2 GB for Devuan.

From Vanilla OS to Devuan

  • You will swap Apx for APT; package names and install commands differ, so check your must-have apps on Devuan first.
  • The desktop changes from GNOME to Xfce, KDE Plasma, more; expect a different layout, settings app and shortcuts.
  • Devuan is a fixed release: fewer surprise changes, but you upgrade to a new version every so often.

Either way, back up your home folder, then do a clean install; reusing a separate /home partition works but can bring old settings that clash.

Devuan vs Vanilla OS: FAQ

Is Devuan better than Vanilla OS?

Neither is better for everyone. Devuan is the stronger pick for older hardware, long-term stability; Vanilla OS for gaming, latest software.

Which uses less RAM, Devuan or Vanilla OS?

Devuan is lighter: we suggest about 2 GB versus 4 GB. The desktop you choose affects memory use more than the distribution itself.

Is Devuan based on Vanilla OS?

No. Devuan is based on Debian; Vanilla OS is based on Debian Sid.

Related comparisons

Add a third distro to this comparison